Business Consulting

Independent director: who they are, what they do and how independence is assessed

Who on the board of directors can say no without owing anything to whoever chose them? Let’s find out in this article.

una prospettiva differente, a simboleggiare il ruolo dell'amministratore indipendente, nella nuova copertina del magazine digitale di Bliss

An independent director is a non-executive member of the board of directors who does not have, and has not recently had, relationships with the company or with those who control it that could compromise their judgement (Corporate Governance Code, 2020). Their role is to bring to the board an assessment free from the interests at stake, above all on decisions in which those who manage or control the company may have an interest of their own.

In listed companies the law requires their presence: at least one, or two if the board has more than seven members (TUF, Art. 147-ter, paragraph 4). This guide explains who they are, what they do and how it is established that they genuinely are independent.

Independent director: meaning and difference from executive and non-executive

Directors are distinguished by their role in management. Executive directors hold delegated powers or managerial positions: these include a chair with executive powers or a role in setting strategy, chief executives and members of the executive committee. Non-executive directors are all the others. Independent directors are non-executives with no current or recent relationships that could affect their independence of judgement (Corporate Governance Code, definitions).

The board works as a system of checks: those who manage propose, the others assess. The more real the weight of non-executive and independent directors, the more the board can correct those in charge.

Executive, non-executive, independent

Three categories of director, in order of distance from management.

CategoryWho it isQuestion it answers
Executive directorHolds delegated powers or management roles: a chair with executive powers, chief executives, members of the executive committeeHow is the company managed?
Non-executive directorHolds no delegated powers or management roles: takes part in board decisions and sits on committeesIs management sound and consistent with the strategy?
Independent directorNon-executive, with no current or recent relationships that could affect their independence of judgementDoes the decision hold up without the interests of those who manage or control the company?

Source: Corporate Governance Code (2020), definitions. Bliss summary. Every independent director is non-executive; not every non-executive is independent.

So who chooses the directors?
In listed companies they are elected by the shareholders’ meeting through slate voting: the slates indicate which candidates meet the independence requirements set by law and by the articles of association (TUF, Art. 147-ter, paragraph 1). Slate voting gives minorities a voice, and directors drawn from a minority slate are known, in short, as minority directors. A director does not become independent by the will of whoever nominates them: the status depends on the requirements and on the board’s assessment of them.

What an independent director does

The work of an independent director is the work of every board member, with one additional focus: judgement free of personal interests. The Corporate Governance Code states that the number and expertise of non-executive directors must ensure significant weight in board resolutions and effective oversight of management, and that a significant proportion must be independent (Principle VI).

This translates into concrete duties. Independent directors sit on the nomination, remuneration, and control and risk committees (the latter oversees the risk management system, the domain of Enterprise Risk Management): on all three, the majority of members must be independent, and the remuneration and the control and risk committees are chaired by an independent director. In large companies they meet among themselves at least once a year, without the other directors. If the chair is also the chief executive or holds significant executive powers, or controls the company, the board appoints a lead independent director: the point of reference for non-executive directors, who coordinates the meetings of the independent directors alone (Code, recommendations 5, 13, 14 and the section on committees).

How many independent directors are required

It depends on the source. The law sets the minimum for listed companies; the Code raises it for those that apply it.

How many independent directors are needed

It depends on the source and the type of company.

  • 1–2at least

    Listed companies

    At least one independent director; two if the board has more than seven members.

    TUF, Art. 147-ter, paragraph 4

  • 2at least

    Companies applying the Code

    At least two independent directors, other than the chair.

    Code, Recommendation 5

  • ⅓of the board

    Large companies with concentrated ownership

    At least one third of the board.

    Code, Recommendation 5

  • ½of the board

    Other large companies

    At least half of the board.

    Code, Recommendation 5

  • ⅓of members

    One-tier system

    At least one third of members (to be verified against the rule).

    Civil Code, art. 2409-septiesdecies

A company is large if its market capitalisation exceeded one billion euros in each of the three preceding calendar years (Code, definitions). Bliss summary.

Under the Code, at least two are required in any case, other than the chair. In large companies with concentrated ownership, independent directors must make up at least one third of the board; in other large companies, at least half. A company is large if its capitalisation exceeded one billion euros on the last trading day of each of the three preceding calendar years (Code, recommendation 5 and definitions). For companies with a one-tier system, the Civil Code requires at least one third of the board to meet the independence requirements (Art. 2409-septiesdecies). These rules concern listed companies and the one-tier system: banks, insurers and public companies may have their own rules, which we do not cover here.

Requirements: how independence is assessed

The law looks at relationships that compromise independence: for directors of listed companies it refers to the requirements set for members of the board of statutory auditors, which exclude, among others, anyone bound to the company or group companies by self-employment or employment relationships, or by other financial or professional relationships that compromise their independence, as well as family members of the directors (TUF, Arts. 147-ter and 148).

The Code is more detailed. Recommendation 7 sets out the circumstances that compromise, or appear to compromise, independence: being a significant shareholder; having held, in the last three financial years, an executive role or employment in the company or in related companies; having, or having had in the last three financial years, a significant commercial, financial or professional relationship; having received, in the last three financial years, significant additional remuneration; having been a director for more than nine of the last twelve financial years; being an executive director of another company on whose board an executive director of the company sits; belonging to the network of the audit firm; being a close family member of anyone in these situations.

The Code sets no numerical thresholds for “significant”: it is for the board to establish quantitative and qualitative criteria at the start of its term. The assessment is made immediately after appointment, during the term whenever circumstances change, and at least once a year (recommendation 6), and the outcome must be disclosed to the market together with the criteria used (recommendation 10). The Code leaves room for judgement: a director may be deemed independent even if one of the circumstances applies, provided there is a clear and reasoned explanation, under the “comply or explain” principle.

The Bliss angle: independence is a relationship

A list of requirements establishes the absence of ties, not the freedom to dissent. Between a director nominated by a controlling shareholder and the person who proposed them, there remains a relationship that no requirement measures: gratitude, the wish to be reappointed, the effort of challenging a meeting where everyone agrees. The Code itself acknowledges this: it looks at substance and allows the board to deem independent someone who shows a formal risk indicator, provided it gives its reasons.

This is why we treat the independent director as a governance question: the role works only if the board enables it to carry weight. Complete information in good time, an explicit mandate, a chair who accepts challenge. And useful dissent is not the same as voting against: it is the work done before the vote, and it is measured by the changes it produces. The same freedom from incentives applies to those who advise: an opinion has value only if whoever gives it does not profit from one of the answers, as we write about the independent advisor and Executive Advisory, which works alongside management and the board without replacing them.

The brand comes in where the board is the final authority: repositionings, extraordinary transactions, names and reputation, succession. These are the decisions in which those in charge have the greatest personal interests, and therefore those in which an independent director is most needed. It is a matter of Brand Governance, and in businesses that revolve around a single person it becomes the flip side of the same problem: key person risk.

The data: how many there are and how listed companies behave

The 2025 Report of the Corporate Governance Committee, which analyses 179 companies adhering to the Code (97% of those listed on Euronext Milan and 99% of market capitalisation) with data for financial year 2024, shows boards becoming steadily more independent. The average share of independent directors is 53%, up from 51% the previous year and 42% in 2015. In large companies it is 62%, in financial companies 69%, and in non-large companies 49% (Corporate Governance Committee, 2025 Report).

How many independent directors sit on Italian boards

Average share of independent directors in listed companies adhering to the Code.

Average share of independent directors on boards

2015
42%
2024
51%
2025
53%

By type of company, 2025

Large companies
62%
Financial companies
69%
Non-large companies
49%

Source: Corporate Governance Committee, 2025 Report (179 adhering companies, 97% of those listed on Euronext Milan; data for the 2024 financial year).

The picture also shows how far independence is a matter of judgement. In the same report, 16% of adhering companies (28) deemed a director independent despite a formal risk indicator, giving case-by-case reasons; the criterion most often disapplied is length of tenure. Independent directors at risk for one or more reasons number 55, across 37 companies, compared with 133 in 2017. 82% of companies disclose the criteria they use to assess the significance of commercial, financial and professional relationships. 54% of companies are in at least one situation that requires a lead independent director, and they appoint one in 79% of cases.

Domande frequenti

What is an independent director?

A non-executive member of the board of directors who does not have, and has not recently had, relationships with the company or with those who control it that could compromise their independence of judgement. In listed companies the law requires at least one, or two if the board has more than seven members, and the Corporate Governance Code asks for more.

What does independent board member mean?

Independent board member and independent director refer to the same figure: a member of the board of directors with no ties that could affect their judgement. The term “independent” does not refer to a qualification or a role, but to a condition verified on appointment and at least once a year, according to criteria the board sets and discloses.

Who is the executive director?

They are directors who hold delegated management powers or management roles in the company or in a significant subsidiary. They include a chair with delegated management powers or powers in setting strategy, chief executives and members of the executive committee. Executives manage, while non-executives assess and monitor the work of those who manage.

What does non-executive director mean?

They are directors without delegated powers or management roles: they do not take part in day-to-day management, but in the decisions of the board and its committees. Independent directors are non-executives with no relationships that could affect their judgement: every independent director is non-executive, but not every non-executive is independent.

Who appoints independent directors?

They are elected by the shareholders’ meeting, in listed companies through slate voting. The slates indicate which candidates meet the independence requirements set by law and by the articles of association. After appointment, the board assesses the independence of each non-executive and discloses the outcome, so independence does not depend on the will of whoever puts the candidate forward.

Who are minority directors?

They are the directors drawn from a minority slate, that is, one submitted by shareholders other than those who control the company. Slate voting allows minorities to be represented on the board. They may also be independent, but the two designations do not coincide: one concerns who nominated them, the other the absence of relationships that could affect their judgement.

How do you become an independent director?

There is no set path or register: you must be elected by the shareholders' meeting, meet the requirements of law and the articles of association, and be judged independent by the board after appointment. What counts is relevant expertise, available time and the absence of significant relationships with the company and its group. Independence is reassessed at least once a year.

What are corporate governance codes?

They are sets of corporate governance recommendations that listed companies choose to apply on a “comply or explain” basis: if they do not follow a recommendation, they explain why. In Italy the reference is the Corporate Governance Code issued by Borsa Italiana’s Corporate Governance Committee, approved in January 2020, which replaced the previous Self-Regulatory Code.

How long can someone remain an independent director?

The Code sets no absolute limit: it lists having served as a director for more than nine financial years in the last twelve as a circumstance that compromises, or appears to compromise, independence. The board may nonetheless deem the director independent with a reasoned justification. According to the Committee’s 2025 Report, it is the criterion listed companies most often disapply.

What does a board director do?

They take part in board decisions, approve strategic plans, prepare the draft financial statements, appoint and oversee those who manage the company, and sit on committees. A director with delegated powers manages; one without them assesses and monitors. Every director is accountable for the decisions they take: the board is not a representative body, but one of decision and oversight.

What is the difference between an independent director and a statutory auditor?

An independent director sits on the board and takes part in decisions; a statutory auditor belongs to the control body, the board of statutory auditors, and oversees without deciding. The independence requirements for directors of listed companies refer to those for statutory auditors, but the two roles remain distinct.

Fonti e riferimenti
  1. Comitato per la Corporate Governance, Codice di Corporate Governance, gennaio 2020
  2. Comitato per la Corporate Governance, Relazione 2025 sull’evoluzione della corporate governance delle società quotate
  3. D.Lgs. 24 febbraio 1998, n. 58 (TUF), artt. 147-ter e 148
  4. Codice civile, art. 2409-septiesdecies
  5. Bliss, Dissenso nel consiglio di amministrazione
  6. Bliss, L’advisor indipendente deve poter dire no
  7. Bliss, Executive Advisory
  8. Bliss, Brand Governance
BLISS®© 2026. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED
Scritto il
Contact