Business Consulting

Scenario planning: deciding when the future could take several directions

We look at how scenarios are built, how they differ from a forecast, and what examples come from companies and institutions.

tre porte su tre scenari, simbolo dello scenario planning nella nuova copertina del magazine digitale di Bliss

Scenario planning, known in Italian as pianificazione per scenari, is a method by which an organisation describes several possible futures that differ from one another and uses them to test its own decisions. Scenarios are narratives of alternative futures that help to understand what they would mean for strategies, policies and stakeholders. They are therefore neither plans nor forecasts, and none of them will come about in full, even though parts of different futures may materialise.

The method sits upstream of the corporate strategic plan, testing how well it holds. A plan written for a single future depends on that one assumption; scenario planning instead asks what would still hold if the context moved in another direction.

Scenario planning in four key points

What scenarios are, how they are built, what they are for

  1. 1They are not forecastsThey are coherent stories of different futures
  2. 2They start from uncertaintiesThe most important ones, independent of each other, often crossed in a 2×2 matrix
  3. 3They test decisionsThey are not meant to guess the future, but to test the choices already on the table
  4. 4They end with two answersWhat to change today and which signals to watch

The Bliss view: a scenario is useful only if it changes a decision

Many scenario exercises produce fine stories and no effect: four carefully described worlds, a presentation, then back to the old plan. That is why, when we work with companies, we judge a scenario by one thing alone: whether it changes a decision taken today.

The test: two lines for each scenario

  1. The decisionThe first choice you would make differently if that scenario were the most likely
  2. The signalWhat would tell you that it is coming true

A scenario without these two lines is an illustration, not a decision-making tool. Further on we will see how this test links to the testing of options, which the UK toolkit calls a stress test.

The Bliss Agency perspective

Scenario planning and forecasting: what is the difference?

Forecasting starts from historical data and projects trends forward, usually by varying a few key assumptions, such as growth in gross domestic product, in a high, a medium and a low scenario. It nonetheless remains grounded in a fixed view of how the system works, and for this reason loses reliability over the long term. Futures thinking, by contrast, starts from the idea that the system itself may change radically, and therefore explores a wider range of possibilities.

This distinction is why the method’s major users insist on the point. Shell, which has been producing scenarios for over fifty years, makes clear that its scenarios are not predictions and do not directly reflect the company’s future actions: they are stories of alternative futures, one of many inputs into strategy. The European Commission’s EU Policy Lab says the same, describing them as stories about visions and possible futures, not as forecasts.

When scenario planning is needed

Scenario planning is at its best when uncertainty is high and decisions are hard to correct. For companies, the typical cases are:

  • multi-year investments that are hard to reverse;
  • entry into new markets or exit from existing ones;
  • dependence on a resource, a supplier or a regulation;
  • review of the strategic plan after a shock.

How to build a scenario plan in five steps

Let us take a horizon of at least five years, or better still ten to twenty years. Looking at this time horizon, to build a scenario plan we will need to:

  1. Identify the drivers. Before building the scenarios, the forces of change (economic, technological, social, environmental, regulatory) are gathered through horizon scanning and ranked on an importance-uncertainty matrix. Competitor analysis is one source of drivers.
  2. Choose the axes of uncertainty. Critical uncertainties are the drivers that are both important and highly uncertain. Two are chosen, independent of each other: crossed, they form a matrix with four quadrants. A predetermined element, that is, a high-impact driver with a certain outcome, is not an axis but features in every scenario.
  3. Describe the four worlds. For each quadrant, set out what the future looks like and how it differs from today, in work, the economy, politics and the environment.
  4. Give each scenario a name. The names should be evocative and consistent with one another, without favouring or penalising any one scenario.
  5. Discuss and document. The scenarios are presented, discussed and put in writing.

From scenarios to decisions: stress testing, signals and review

The end point is not the narrative but the testing of choices. This is why the Futures Toolkit describes policy stress-testing, also called wind-tunnelling: each group takes a scenario and assesses every option as robust, redundant or to be modified, without altering the logic of the scenario. The results are gathered in a table with the options in columns and the scenarios in rows. The following example is invented, to illustrate the logic.

The options tested across the four scenarios
OptionScenario 1Scenario 2Scenario 3Scenario 4
Open a second plant Robust To be modified To be modified Redundant
Diversify suppliers Robust Robust Robust Robust
Postpone hiring Redundant Robust Robust Robust

An option that is robust across all scenarios can be decided straight away. The others should be reviewed, or held back pending a signal.

Options that are robust across all scenarios are natural candidates for the plan; those that work in only one are bets, and should be treated as such. To manage time, the toolkit also suggests defining how progress will be monitored and at which points the exercise will be revisited. Weak signals, defined in the glossary as early indications of change gathered through horizon scanning, serve precisely to recognise which scenario is drawing closer. This is a bridge to the continuous review of plans and to strategy execution, which we address in a dedicated piece.

Common mistakes in scenario planning

The most frequent mistakes stem from the very rules the sources themselves set out.

  • Treating a scenario as a forecast and assigning it a “base case” probability. The toolkit makes clear that no scenario will come about in full.
  • Choosing axes of uncertainty that depend on each other, because the quadrants then cease to be genuinely different.
  • Choosing names that reward or penalise a scenario, and so steer the discussion before it has even begun.
  • Stopping at the description and not stress-testing the options.

Domande frequenti

What is scenario planning?

It is a method that describes several alternative futures and uses them to test an organisation’s decisions. Scenarios are coherent narratives, neither forecasts nor plans: they serve to understand what would change for strategies and stakeholders in different contexts and to recognise the signals of change in advance.

What are scenarios for?

They serve to explore how the context might evolve, to understand how the actors involved would behave, to test future decisions and trade-offs, and to identify opportunities and threats. Their purpose is to improve today’s choices, not to guess which future will materialise.

What is the difference between scenario planning and forecasting?

Forecasting projects historical trends by varying a few assumptions, usually in a high, a medium and a low scenario, and remains tied to a fixed view of the system. Scenario planning accepts that the system itself may change and compares qualitatively different futures. That is why it holds up better over the long term.

How many scenarios should be built?

In the method described by the UK toolkit there are four, obtained by crossing two axes of uncertainty in a 2x2 matrix. Alternative approaches exist, including morphological ones. What matters is that the scenarios differ from one another and have names that do not favour any one of them.

What time horizon is used?

The British toolkit, designed for public policy, recommends a horizon of at least five years and more often ten to twenty. A company can shorten it according to the pace of its sector, but the horizon must be long enough for the context to change significantly.

What is risk-based scenario planning?

It is not a term defined by any regulation or standard we have found. In practice it refers to scenario analysis applied to risks, as the Financial Stability Institute does for climate-related financial risks: scenarios are defined, impacts are assessed and the results are communicated.

What is a strategy stress test?

It is the testing of each strategic option against each scenario, also called wind-tunnelling. For each option-scenario pair, the option is assessed as robust, redundant or to be modified. The options that hold up across several scenarios are the safest to include in the plan.

Does scenario planning replace the strategic plan?

No. The strategic plan sets out objectives and actions; scenario planning tests whether those objectives and actions hold up in different contexts. The two tools are complementary: scenarios inform the plan and indicate its review points, while the plan turns choices into commitments.

Fonti e riferimenti
  1. GO-Science, Governo del Regno Unito, “The Futures Toolkit” (seconda edizione, 2024)
  2. EU Policy Lab, Joint Research Centre, Commissione europea, “How do we build scenarios in a foresight exercise?” (2 luglio 2019)
  3. Shell, “Shell Scenarios”
  4. Shell, “The Shell Scenarios team: Modelling the energy transition”, Shell TechXplorer Digest (2024)
  5. Bank for International Settlements, Financial Stability Institute, “Climate risks: scenario analysis - Executive Summary” (31 maggio 2023)
BLISS®© 2026. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED
Scritto il
Contact