Business Consulting

What we would have done to save Blockbuster

In 2004 it should have prepared the transformation. In 2010 it should have found the resources to sustain it through the crisis. Today, with its last store, the challenge concerns the future of a place that has become unique. Three moments to understand which decisions we would have proposed, and under what conditions.

Ultimo Blockbuster, copertina del magazine digitale di Bliss

Last night, when I got home, I found my partner in bed watching a TV comedy series I had never heard of: Blockbuster. Out of curiosity, I lay down next to her to watch it.

The series (cancelled after its first season, as fate would have it) followed the fortunes of a last, hypothetical Blockbuster still open despite every streaming platform and every change in our society. A relic of the past, still alive today, with all the comic twists that implies. 
Now: in itself, it was not a subject that interested me. And yet I found myself following the last episodes of the season despite not having seen the first ones, and knowing there would be no sequel. A bit like watching the video of a crash you know is coming, yet you cannot look away. 
On reflection, it is Blockbuster the company, not just the TV series, whose story is that of a tragedy foretold. The perfect example of a world that moves on and cannot (like it or not) take everything with it. 
It is natural that some things have to be let go. It does not matter how many memories we keep of them. I, for instance, remember the chain with affection and bitterness at two moments in my life at least. The first is when, in the early 2000s, it opened a few metres from my home. For my father and me, it was a custom to go looking for films together and lose ourselves among the shelves. Film night was an event: it was a ritual. Good times. 
The second, a little later, is in the early 2010s, when every Friday at secondary school (in the first years at least), my friends and I would go to the shop to look for a film for our horror-and-pizza night. And anything could happen: stumbling upon masterpieces like Fight Club, well-loved B-movies like Dead Silence, or outright cinematic disasters (Funny Games-style…). However it went, the night was a success.
Shortly afterwards came Netflix, Prime and the streaming channels we know today. And with them, film night would lose its meaning too. 
And so, watching the series, I caught myself thinking that, after all, the world was a better place when Blockbuster still existed. It is a pity that it failed. 
But was all this truly inevitable? Could something have been done? 

Knowing the ending, it is easy to point to the solution: Blockbuster should have bet everything on streaming. But when we open the company’s filings, we find a more complicated story. I looked into it: Blockbuster had in fact developed subscriptions, integrated stores with rental by post, acquired a digital distribution business and brought films to connected devices.

Change, then, had entered the business. The problem was working out how to fund it, and which model to apply.

In that scenario, what would we have proposed had we been called to the table?

To commemorate my memories of the company, I chose hypothetical scenarios in which to intervene, tied to three particular moments: 2004, before the financial emergency; September 2010, on entering Chapter 11; and the present, with the last real store still open in Oregon.

A small experiment to understand how Bliss would have worked on the Bloockbuster brand: before, during and after the crisis.  

Blockbuster series poster
Poster for the series that sparked the idea for this experiment. 

Before stepping in: what did we want to save?

The brand, the company, the stores and the relationship with customers have fates that can diverge.

A business can keep many outlets open while losing its capacity to invest. It can close some of them and retain a commercial relationship. In short, not everything moves in parallel. 

That is why the first step (in each of the three scenarios) would have been to ask the leadership to define the expected outcome: which service to keep offering, to which customers and with what financial means.

Probably the main asset to preserve was Blockbuster’s recognisability, the habits built around its name and the chance of still being chosen for a film night. How much of that asset could be transferred to digital would have needed to be tested.

Scenario 1. In 2004: buying time to change

2004 is the brand’s real watershed. After that date, everything would change. So there was still time to do everything. 

As genuinely happens in our day-to-day consultations with businesses and companies, in that case too we would not have taken the brand for granted. We would have asked, back then, how long the store would keep its role while alternative ways of getting a film were being developed.

The first task would have been to study customers: who was visiting less, which alternatives they were using, and how much convenience, price and title availability mattered.

From there we would have built a plan with two linked responsibilities: keeping the existing business economically sustainable and preparing the next one.

Preserving resources for the transition

In September 2004 Blockbuster used borrowed funds to pay shareholders, including Viacom: a special distribution of approximately $905.6 million. Was it a mistake? 

Before approving it, we would have tested that choice for sustainability against the transformation: what resources would have remained for investment, any initial losses and the reduction of the network?

Our proposal would have been to preserve greater financial flexibility, assessing the alternatives and negotiable terms with the financial advisers. We cannot claim that the entire sum was freely available for a new project, nor attribute the whole outcome of the crisis to that transaction.

We can, however, identify a decision to discuss: how much capital to commit today without compromising tomorrow’s options.

Turning part of the network into a laboratory

At that point we would have selected a few markets to test an integrated relationship: online selection, home delivery, in-store returns and staff assistance.

The store could have guided customers towards a new way of consuming. Testing this required data on the cost of the service, subscriber retention and the overall spending of the households involved.

Blockbuster did in fact take a similar path with Total Access. In the third quarter of 2007 it changed prices and promotions to improve profitability; total subscribers fell from around 3.6 to 3.1 million between July and September. According to the company, the changes reduced the share of unprofitable subscribers.

Putting someone in charge of change

At that point we would have proposed to the board an explicit mandate for the transformation, with investment approved in phases and periodic reviews.

Store managers’ incentives would also have needed to recognise the value of customers guided towards the new services. Otherwise a choice that benefited the company could have looked harmful to the individual store.

It is a typical change management problem: people need objectives and tools that fit the direction required of them, otherwise they lose their way. 

The main risk would have remained the pace of the transition. Shrinking the network too early could have eroded revenues that were still needed; waiting too long would have kept absorbing resources. The plan would have had to provide for both eventualities.

It is in 2009 that we begin to see a clear divergence between the financial trajectories of Blockbuster and Netflix: the crisis had become visible.

Scenario 2. In 2010: giving the restructuring a future

On 23 September 2010 Blockbuster and certain US subsidiaries filed for protection under Chapter 11. In its corporate filings the company describes growing competition, debt obligations and liquidity constraints that had limited the implementation of its strategic initiatives.

By that point, time had run out. Every proposal would have had to explain how to get to the following week and which business to fund beyond the emergency.

In a crisis of this kind, we would have worked alongside the financial and legal restructuring specialists, focusing our contribution on the offer model, the customer relationship and the direction of the brand.

Digital was already on the table

Blockbuster had acquired Movielink in 2007 and integrated the offering into blockbuster.com in 2008. In 2009 it had developed its On Demand service, partly through agreements with Samsung and TiVo.

Proposing a digital presence in 2010 would therefore have been consistent with existing activities. We would have needed to establish how to make them more competitive and sustainable.

The review would have covered catalogue, rights, reachable devices, ease of use, technology costs and transaction margins. We would have separated single-film rental from subscription: two offerings to be assessed with their own agreements and accounts.

Seeking a partner with a precise proposal

At such a delicate moment, we would have explored an agreement with a technology operator, a distributor or an investor able to support its development.

We would have brought a tightly defined proposal to the negotiation: which assets to capitalise on, which customers to reach, what investment to request and how to allocate costs, revenues and responsibilities.

The value of the brand would have had to be proven through its ability to generate usage and purchases. Any transfer of customer relationships would also have required a review of the applicable rights and conditions.

Had the offer attracted interest, we would have proposed a limited pilot, with defined objectives and resources. Without a partner or sustainable conditions, the project would have needed to be reassessed quickly.

Choosing which stores could sustain the future

The network would have required a store-by-store analysis: economic contribution, contractual commitments, exit cost and any role in the new model.

Some stores could have continued to generate cash. Others could have helped customers access the new services. For others still, closure would have been the option to examine.

None of these decisions would have freed up resources automatically: exiting a contract, reducing headcount and reorganising operations all take time and money.

The cash plan would have needed to include them, together with the sums required to sustain the digital component.

Setting conditions for continuing

We would have asked for a restructuring lead with clear authority, a cash plan updated every week and closely spaced decision points.

For digital, the indicators would have included repeat usage, margin after relevant costs, acquisition cost and service reliability. The board would have had to establish in advance which results would justify further investment.

Our hypothesis would have been a smaller Blockbuster, with a central digital component and a partner able to support it.

The risk was real: insufficient capital, unfavourable rights or weak customer interest could have made this path unworkable too. In that case, preserving some operations through a sale might have offered better prospects than the continuity of the company as a whole.

one of the last Blockbusters to close
The last Blockbuster still open today is in Bend, Oregon, and is run by manager Sandi Harding.

Scenario 3. Today: protecting the future of the last Blockbuster

And yet Blockbuster is not over.
Despite everything, in Bend, Oregon, one store still exists: the last one (just as in the TV series). 

It is a local business that joined the franchise in 2000 and also sustains itself through merchandise sales. We hope manager Sandi Harding keeps it going for as long as possible. Purely as an experiment, though, we would like to ask: how could it become an institution?

Understanding how much each business earns

If we were to step in at Blockbuster today, we would probably start with the accounts for rentals, merchandising, online sales and any special initiatives, including staff time and running costs. A full audit. 

International attention can bring visits and orders. But it needs to be understood how much they can contribute to continuity, and how much work they require.

Proposing experiences and products in generic terms would add little: in 2020 the store had already hosted an initiative with Airbnb that allowed some local residents to spend the night among the shelves. The point here is to understand which initiatives can become recurring without burdening the store or taking space away from regular customers.

The age of nostalgia

Beyond defining choices around sponsors, products and events, we would make Bend a true temple of nostalgia: a place of unique experiences with the flavour of days gone by. We would then host on-site film and junk food nights, screening films of every kind (just as I used to do as a kid): timeless cult classics, B-movies, great holiday favourites. All accompanied by themed food and ironic, light, simple communication. 

No binge-watching, no scrolling in search of the right film. 
The right moment, the right company: nothing else is needed.  

Times change, identity remains 

In short, across the thousand scenarios to explore, there are many ways in which Blockbuster could have been (or could still be) turned around.
As bad luck would have it, Bliss did not work on the case, but a timeless truth can still be drawn from this lesson. 
In 2004 we would have sought to preserve the resources and the relationship needed to change the model.

In 2010 we would have sought sustainable continuity, assessing digital, partners and downsizing.
Today, in Bend, we would work on nostalgia and authentic experiences.

In every scenario, what we would have brought to the surface is the brand’s identity, without subterfuge and without reinvention. Because when an organisation manages to become part of people’s lives, what it needs is already there, within reach. 

Times change, and the only thing that needs to change is the way that uniqueness is expressed.
Which, in Blockbuster’s case, was never film rental, but the moments that experience let people live at home.

Domande frequenti

Why did Blockbuster go into crisis?

Company filings describe a combination of competition, changes in entertainment distribution, debt obligations and liquidity constraints. Reducing the story to a mere failure to adopt streaming leaves out digital businesses already under way and significant financial problems.

Did Blockbuster already have a digital service?

Yes. It acquired Movielink in 2007, integrated its offer into the website and developed Blockbuster On Demand. Before 2010 it already had agreements to distribute content through connected devices.

Would it have been too late to bet on streaming in 2010?

It was a path worth assessing, including by building on existing operations. Its feasibility depended on funding, content rights, the competitiveness of the offer and the ability to sustain the transition during the crisis.

Would closing stores have saved Blockbuster?

On its own, downsizing would not have guaranteed survival. It would have required an assessment of exit costs and of the resources that could be freed up, together with a model capable of generating sustainable revenue.

Where is the last Blockbuster?

The store is in Bend, Oregon. Its website describes it as the last Blockbuster store left in the world since March 2019.

Is the last Blockbuster at risk of closing?

The sources used do not support the claim that a closure is imminent. The proposed scenario concerns the future continuity of the business, without assuming a current crisis.

What does Brand Advisory contribute in a case like this?

Assessing the role of the brand, customers' reasons for choosing it and the coherence of the commercial alternatives. In a turnaround, this work must be integrated with that of financial, legal, technology and operational specialists.

Fonti e riferimenti
  1. Blockbuster Inc., Form 10-K, esercizio chiuso il 31 dicembre 2006
  2. Blockbuster Inc., Form 10-Q, trimestre chiuso il 30 settembre 2007
  3. Blockbuster Inc., Form 10-K, esercizio chiuso il 3 gennaio 2010
  4. Blockbuster Inc., Form 10-K, esercizio chiuso il 2 gennaio 2011
  5. Blockbuster Bend, About Us
  6. Airbnb, The Last Blockbuster
BLISS®© 2026. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED
Scritto il
Contact