Brand Advisory

Retail advisory: what it is, what it covers and when you need retail consultancy

What is retail advisory, and what changes for a consumer-facing business when it decides to rely on an advisor? In this guide we explore what retail consultancy involves, the areas it covers and how it differs from related forms of consultancy. We will also look at when it is needed, how an engagement unfolds and how to choose the right professional.

negozio fisico, curato da un retail advisor, nella nuova copertina del magazine digitale di Bliss

Retail advisory is the advisory work that supports those operating in retail (that is, retailers, brands with their own stores, property owners and investors) in decisions on format, location, shopping experience, channels and store performance. Retail is the activity of those who professionally buy goods in their own name and on their own account and resell them directly to the end consumer (Legislative Decree 114/1998). Retail consulting is a specialisation of management consulting: it provides strategic guidance and operational support to optimise operations, improve the customer experience and increase profitability (Umbrex).

The term is still new in Italian and is currently used with different meanings: for some it means real estate advisory, for others network strategy, for others still the training of shop staff. We try to bring order to these diverging definitions, and add the lens most characteristic of Bliss: the point of sale is where the buyer tests a brand’s promise. That is why, when we talk about retail advisory, we hold together economic and brand decisions, which are usually treated separately.

Retail advisory, retail consulting and consulenza retail: the same name, different jobs

Retail consultancy is often confused with other activities. In this table we distinguish its real function from what other sources claim it does.

ApproachWhat it doesExample activities
Real estate advisory Supports retailers, developers, investors and banks in the valuation, management and development of commercial assets Feasibility studies, catchment area analysis, tenant advisory (Kroll)
Market intelligence and strategic advisory Analyses consumption, offer and positioning, and helps with planning Consumer insight, business plans, ESG advisory (Nomisma)
Growth and network consultancy Supports the development of the format, franchising and sites Store concept, location selection, commercial management (RPM Consulting)
Retail management consulting Works across strategy, customer experience, operations, sales, e-commerce, supply chain and finance Omnichannel, store layout, pricing, inventory (Umbrex)

These are four ways of looking at the same sector, each with its own clients and expertise. A well-located shop whose experience is inconsistent with the brand still loses, and vice versa.

The areas of retail advisory

Strategy, positioning and format

This is where you decide what is sold, to whom and in what type of shop. Retail management consulting covers entry into new markets, competitive positioning, franchising and multi-site expansion, through to M&A transactions (Umbrex). For a brand, the starting question here is whether the shop is a sales channel or a brand space: the answers lead to very different formats and investments, so clarity is essential. We discussed this earlier this summer in the case of K-beauty opening physical stores around the world.

Location and property

Location search combines the choice of setting (shopping centre, historic centre, outlet, station) with geomarketing: catchment area, target, cannibalisation between stores, footfall and turnover estimates (RPM Consulting). Real estate advisory adds investment analysis, feasibility studies and advice to tenants on negotiations (Kroll). In this area the numbers matter, but a location has no value in itself: it matters for the people who frequent it and for what the brand represents there.

Customer experience and channels

This is the area where retail advisory meets the brand. It covers omnichannel, customer journey mapping, loyalty programmes and personalisation (Umbrex). The point is to coordinate what happens in store with what happens online, so that the customer does not perceive two different companies.

Brands are investing in physical spaces again: we have already covered this in our piece on brand experience and physical spaces.

Operations, layout and people

This branch of retail advisory concerns how the shop is actually organised: layout and visual merchandising, staff training, standardisation of operations across multi-site networks (Umbrex), recruitment, performance indicators and mystery shopping (RPM Consulting). Sales staff are the most visible part of this area: the retail advisor, the professional who guides customers through their choice, is the subject of our in-depth piece on who the retail advisor is, their role and salaries.

Performance and control

It includes margin analysis, cost reduction, risk management and store portfolio management, including lease negotiations (Umbrex). In a store network, these are the decisions that free up resources for the other areas: closing or redesigning an underperforming store requires data, but also a brand criterion to distinguish what needs correcting from what needs defending.

Types of retail outlet: the legal framework

The law distinguishes retail outlets by floor area. Under the original wording of Legislative Decree 114/1998, neighbourhood shops go up to 150 square metres in municipalities with fewer than 10,000 inhabitants and up to 250 in larger ones; medium-sized outlets go up to 1,500 and 2,500 square metres; above these thresholds they are classed as large outlets. A shopping centre is a medium-sized or large outlet in which several retail shops sit within a purpose-built facility, with shared infrastructure and centrally managed services.

TypeMunicipalities with up to 10,000 inhabitantsMunicipalities with over 10,000 inhabitants
Neighbourhood shop up to 150 sq m up to 250 sq m
Medium-sized retail outlet up to 1,500 sq m up to 2,500 sq m
Large retail outlet over 1,500 sq m over 2,500 sq m

Thresholds from the original, non-updated wording of Legislative Decree 114/1998. They may have been amended by later laws and by regional and municipal regulations: they must be checked for each specific case.

For all these reasons, a shop’s format is not merely a commercial choice, and the task of retail advisory is to steer the client towards the best possible solution.

When retail advisory is needed

Retail advisory becomes useful when a costly decision is about to be taken with little information, or with conflicting information. The typical moments, as we see them:

  1. Opening a new shop, especially if it is the first or if the format is changing.
  2. Network expansion, including through franchising, which requires repeatable standards.
  3. A brand’s entry into physical retail, starting from a business born online.
  4. The loss of relevance of a shop or an entire network, when sales fall without a clear cause.
  5. Coordination across channels, when shop, website and social media say different things.
  6. A change of ownership or investors, which calls for an independent assessment of the assets.

In none of these cases does consultancy replace the decision. Retail advisory serves to make it informed and to bring to the table the alternatives that the organisation, on its own, tends not to see.

How a retail advisory engagement unfolds

Engagements follow different patterns depending on the consultant. The sequence we describe is our own, and we use it as a checklist for understanding what to expect.

Independence

Those who also sell software or property have a stake in the recommendation. This is not grounds for exclusion, but it must be declared.

Data and method

The consultant must state which data they will use, where it comes from and how it will be verified.

Comparable cases

Experience in luxury does not automatically transfer to a neighbourhood store network, and vice versa.

Reading the brand

A shop is also a brand space: if the advisor ignores this, the recommendation risks optimising the wrong number.

Accountability for results

Better indicators agreed in advance than generic promises.

The sign of a good engagement is that, at the end, the client knows what to do and why, even without the consultant.

How to choose a retail consultant

There is no professional register or single career path, so the choice comes down to evidence. Some criteria of our own:

  • Independence. Those who also sell software or property have a stake in the recommendation: this is not grounds for exclusion, but it must be declared.
  • Data and method. The consultant must state which data they will use, where it comes from and how it will be verified.
  • Comparable cases. Experience in luxury does not automatically transfer to a neighbourhood store network, and vice versa.
  • Reading the brand. A shop is also a brand space: if the advisor ignores this, the recommendation risks optimising the wrong number.
  • Accountability for results. Indicators agreed in advance are better than generic promises.

The retail advisor: who they are

Is the retail advisor the person who carries out retail advisory? In practice the term has two meanings. The first refers to the professional who advises companies and store networks, the subject of this guide. The second, common in retail job adverts, refers to the person who assists customers with their purchase in store, often in fashion and luxury.

The Bliss angle: the shop as proof of the brand

For Bliss, the shop is the proof of the brand: what a brand claims in its campaigns is tested in store, with the buyer’s body, time and money. This is why we see retail advisory as a twofold job that has to answer two questions.

Is this store performing?

Does this shop resemble what we promise?

Those who optimise only the former risk building networks that are efficient and indistinguishable. For reading the brand in luxury, see our guide to brand strategy for luxury.

When the two questions contradict each other, the advisor’s task is to show the price of each choice and leave the decision to the board. A network that gives up some immediate profitability to protect brand consistency may well be right.

What matters is that the choice is deliberate, not the result of a lack of data.

Bliss’s point of view

Bliss and retail advisory: the Doreca case

In our project for Doreca, a Ho.Re.Ca. distribution operator with a network of stores serving both professionals and consumers, we chose to work on the relationship between physical presence, brand identity and digital channels. The starting point was observation in the field: store visits, analysis of purchasing flows and discussions with staff and Ho.Re.Ca. professionals. From this reading we defined the positioning, messages and priorities of a strategy able to hold together audiences with different needs.

Between February and November 2023 we handled 7 of the 14 new stores opened by Doreca, producing dedicated creative work, poster campaigns, photo and video content, geotargeted campaigns and opening initiatives for each one. In the stores already trading we worked on product placement, promotions, in-store events and staff training: in 2023 the conversion rate rose by 8% and the average transaction value by 12% (Doreca internal data).

The work translated into coordination between store communications, social media, e-commerce and advertising campaigns. Each launch thus became an opportunity to make Doreca recognisable locally, while maintaining continuity with the other channels. This link is where our contribution to retail advisory was focused: starting from what happens in store to guide brand choices and turn them into coordinated, measurable activities.

Domande frequenti

What is retail advisory?

Retail advisory is the consultancy that supports retailers, brands with their own stores, property owners and investors in decisions on format, location, shopping experience, channels and store performance. It is a specialisation of management consulting, providing strategic guidance and operational support to retail businesses (Umbrex).

What is the difference between retail advisory and retail consulting?

In current usage they are almost synonymous: retail consulting is the more widespread term for management consulting applied to retail, while retail advisory often appears in real estate, for example in advisory on investments and commercial assets. The difference depends on who is using the term, not on a shared definition.

What does a retail advisor do?

It depends on the meaning. As a consultant, they analyse data and alternatives to help retailers and brands decide on format, location, channels and customer experience. In job adverts, often in fashion and luxury, the term refers to the person who assists customers with their purchase in store. Before responding to an advert or an assignment, it is worth clarifying which of the two is meant.

When is retail consulting needed?

It is needed when a costly decision is about to be taken with little information: opening a new shop, expanding a network, moving from digital to a physical store, a drop in performance with no clear cause, integrating channels. It does not replace the board's decision: it prepares it.

Who is retail advisory for?

Physical and online retailers, brands with their own or franchised stores, consumer goods manufacturers, owners of and investors in commercial property, and funds investing in retail. The type of client determines the scope of the engagement, such as network strategy or the valuation of an asset (Umbrex, Kroll).

What are the areas of retail advisory?

The recurring ones are format strategy and positioning, location and property, customer experience and channels, operations and people, performance and control. Some consultants focus on a single area, such as geomarketing or staff training; others cover the entire cycle.

How are retail outlets classified in Italy?

Legislative Decree 114/1998, in its original wording, distinguishes neighbourhood shops, medium-sized outlets and large outlets according to sales area and the size of the municipality. A shopping centre is a facility in which several shops sit within a single complex with shared services. Thresholds and rules must be checked against current legislation.

How do you choose a retail consultant?

It is worth assessing independence, method, cases comparable to your own sector, the ability to read the brand beyond the numbers, and performance indicators agreed before the engagement. A consultant who declares their interests and explains which data they will use is generally more reliable than one who promises results without specifying them.

Does retail advisory also cover e-commerce?

Yes, when e-commerce is part of a channel strategy. Retail consulting includes choosing and integrating platforms, digital payments and personalised recommendations (Umbrex). For a brand with physical shops, the point is for online and in-store to offer a consistent experience, not to feel like two different companies.

How much does retail consultancy cost?

There is no single fee and we have no reliable data to report: it depends on duration, scope, client and the consultant's profile. It is best to request a quote setting out activities, expected results and measurement criteria, and to compare several offers with the same scope.

Fonti e riferimenti
  1. Umbrex, “What is retail consulting?”
  2. Kroll, “Consulenza specialistica retail”
  3. Nomisma, “Consulting for the retail market”
  4. RPM Consulting, “Consulenza retail”
  5. D.Lgs. 31 marzo 1998, n. 114, art. 4 (testo originale)
BLISS®© 2026. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED
Scritto il
Contact