Brand Advisory

Armies without generals, or generals without armies: what is left of the brand after marketing cuts

A brand whose marketing is cut almost always ends up without an army, without a general or without both, and the trouble is that from the outside it does not show. Let us look at what an army without leadership and leadership without an army look like inside a company.

scacchiera con pezzi senza re da una parte, e solo con re dall'altra, nella nuova copertina del magazine digitale di Bliss

In 401 BC, on the plain of Cunaxa, not far from Babylon, ten thousand Greek soldiers won their battle but lost the war. The prince who had hired them, Cyrus, had just died on the field. Later, during negotiations, five of their generals were lured by deception and taken prisoner.

They were left stranded in the heart of the Persian Empire, months of marching from the sea. They knew how to fight. Now they had to work out who would lead them home. They had everything an army needs, except one thing: someone who could tell them where to go.

Xenophon, who was there, recounts that the following night only a few ate; some lit a fire, many lay down wherever they happened to be, unable to sleep. Around midnight, the surviving generals and senior officers met. The priority was to replace the lost commanders. Before choosing the route, before counting the provisions, they chose who would command. Among the new generals would be Xenophon himself, who until then had held no authority at all.

When marketing is cut, something very similar happens to a brand. Among the companies we work with, it is the cut we see most often, and it is clear why: it is the most visible line item and the one whose returns are hardest to prove. Yet what remains afterwards is almost always one of two cases: an army without a general, or a general without an army.

The army without a general

The most common case, and perhaps the most deceptive, because the army does not stop. The people have stayed, and they are good. The editorial calendar goes out every week and campaigns launch on schedule. Each piece of work, taken on its own, is sound. What is missing is someone accountable for all of it together: an individual (or a group of individuals) who can say what the brand will never say and who has the authority to stop a well-crafted message that leads elsewhere.

So every soldier marches zealously in their own direction. A brand that works this way sees nothing happen for months. The noise does not drop, the activity numbers stay good, and nobody notices that the brand has begun saying slightly different things to everyone it meets. The customer notices, years later, when they can no longer explain to a friend what sets that brand apart from the others.

It is a question of headcount before it is a question of creativity.

The general without an army

Absurd as it may sound, this case makes even less noise. Here we have a brand director with a solid three-year plan and a carefully crafted identity manual, but a team cut down to two people (one of whom may even be in their first year). They know exactly where the brand should go: the problem is that, in this case, the general has no one to send.

The plan stays in a document and authority becomes a title on a business card. Every morning that director has to choose what to leave behind. They choose well, mind you, because they know what matters. But a strategy that is only minimally executed becomes a different strategy. And in the long run it is the calendar, not the vision, that decides what the brand is.

Why nobody notices

The Greeks, at least, knew they had lost their commanders. They realised it at once, and before dawn they had already acted. A company today, by contrast, can remain in this same condition for years without noticing, because the soldiers keep marching and the general still has an office. Nothing shows up on the cost sheet: spending is down, the activity is there, the plan exists.

The reason is time, and it is also why cuts start with marketing. A cut has an immediate effect: you find it in that period’s income statement, for the exact amount. Brand dilution takes years, and when it reaches revenue no one links it to the decision that caused it. The chief financial officer is judged on the period and must deliver results quickly, and rightly so, while whoever governs the brand thinks on a horizon of years. When the two perspectives do not talk to each other, the faster one wins and the brand pays the price.

A study of 41 beer and cider brands gives us an idea of what it costs to stop being seen: after broad-reach advertising was suspended, sales fell by 16% after one year, 25% after two and 36% after three (Ehrenberg-Bass Institute, Journal of Advertising Research, 2021). It is a sample of beverages, and the Institute itself warns that for slower-moving goods the effect may arrive later. Yet the point stands, and I like to read this figure as an order of magnitude of what silence can cost.

A brand is an intangible asset, and an asset that wears away without making a sound is the hardest to defend.

Many Greeks did not sleep a wink that night. Before dawn they already had new leaders. Nobody loses sleep over a brand without a general or without an army: the logo is where it should be and the numbers add up. The first problem is that everyone sleeps soundly.

Domande frequenti

What happens to a brand when marketing is cut too deeply?

The risk is an imbalance between strategy and execution. You may be left with an operational team without a guide capable of maintaining coherence and direction, or with brand leadership lacking the resources to turn strategy into concrete activity. In both cases the brand keeps working, but gradually loses recognisability and coherence.

Why do the effects of a marketing cut often show up late?

Because cost reduction delivers an immediate financial benefit, whereas the weakening of the brand tends to emerge over time. Reduced presence, inconsistent messaging and loss of distinctiveness can take months or years to be reflected in revenue, making it harder to link the outcome to the original decision.

How do you avoid having a brand without a general or without an army?

What is needed is a balance between governance and operational capacity. The brand must have someone with enough authority to protect direction, priorities and consistency, but also an organisation capable of executing that vision. Strategy without resources and resources without leadership both lead to a loss of value over the long term.

Fonti e riferimenti
  1. Senofonte, Anabasi, libro III, sezioni 1-2 (traduzione inglese)
  2. Hartnett N., Gelzinis A., Beal V., Kennedy R., Sharp B., When brands go dark: Examining sales trends when brands stop broad-reach advertising for long periods (Journal of Advertising Research, 2021)
  3. Ehrenberg-Bass Institute, Scientific proof that going dark kills brands: all the stats marketers need to defend their budgets
BLISS®© 2026. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED
Scritto il
Contact