A man walks into a room and starts shouting. Everyone turns round.
Now tell me: did he communicate well? If we counted only the heads that turned, we might say yes.
After all, he caught their attention and distracted them from what they were doing.
Now, let’s try staying in the room a little longer. What happens?
Someone comes closer, someone else goes back to their phone. Many open the door and leave, alarmed.
This is more or less what I picture when I hear that, for a brand, the first thing to do is grab attention. Good or bad – people often say, misquoting poor Oscar Wilde – what matters is being talked about. And granted, it’s true: you need to be seen, find occasions to meet the public, have something worth the listener’s time. It’s just that we must learn to read what happens when we speak, because if we settle for heads turning and stop looking at what happens next, we will never do anything with that attention.
A good brand strategy should always ask with what expectation people are brought closer. Because the truth is this: the way we call them already shapes half the encounter.
The promise made at the door
A hotel wants to fill its rooms and presents itself as a refuge of absolute silence. The photos are beautiful, the campaign works. Guests arrive looking for seclusion, only to find children whining in the pool. Granted, the hotel is wonderful, and silence would have been lovely there. But there is no silence, and the people drawn in by the story are not the target. The promise made has not been kept: guests will remember the pool more than the fine property.
It happens with almost everything. “The secret nobody tells you” sets up a revelation. “The method that changes everything” sets up a miracle. But if behind these lines there is only (and always) ordinary advice, readers have to scale back on their own what they had been led to imagine. The headline won the click. The content, however, inherits a debt.
This is why a brand identity is also recognised by its promises. You can be witty, surprising, even loud, when the context allows. But those who arrive must find a reason to believe it was worth it. Otherwise it was merely wasted time and resources.
The cost of being misunderstood
In a company, the cost of a broken promise is not paid by whoever made it, but by other departments. If marketing celebrates a thousand enquiries, it is sales who then have to deal with prospects drawn in by different services.
A contact is an opportunity, but if winning that opportunity meant broadening or blurring the offer, the clarifications must go on the bill too. And they always carry a cost, even when hidden (if only in the time it will take to explain what was said superficially).
And when the volume drops?
Whoever shouts once is forced to shout ever louder. Yesterday’s promise seems too weak, the usual tone too composed, the content not spectacular enough. Greater intensity is sought before understanding what relationship yesterday’s produced.
It is not a question of length (in the magazine we have already debunked the myth of the attention span). Six seconds are enough to say something worthwhile. An hour, on the other hand, can be full of exaggeration. The point is what a message leads people to believe.
Whoever signs off a campaign should ask to see, next to the message, the first experience the customer will actually have. The headline next to the page that opens. The advertising promise next to the salesperson’s reply. The photo of the room next to the view from the window. If a lengthy justification is needed between the two, something already needs fixing.
This applies to those who commission our work, too. Before asking for a stronger message, you need to know which promise the company can keep. From there, a great deal can be invented, with freedom and craft. Without that answer, the call becomes a plea for attention: turn round, stop, give me a second. Then – and only then – we’ll work out what to tell you.
So let’s go back to that room. People have turned round; they are looking at us. Do we have something to say that is worth the interruption? If the answer is no, the problem is not theirs, but ours. And raising our voice further is unlikely to solve it.
Domande frequenti
Why can widely viewed content create a problem for the brand?
It can attract people whose expectations differ from what the company offers. In that case, views must be weighed alongside the relevance of enquiries, the work of clarification and the customer's subsequent experience.
Should a brand avoid strong tones or provocative content?
The choice depends on identity, context and content. A strong tone can be appropriate if the offer delivers what the message leads people to imagine. The test is the match between invitation and experience.
How do you assess the quality of the attention gained?
You compare the expectations of the people reached with the actual offer. Relevant enquiries, understanding of the terms and consistency between message and service help to read the result beyond the click alone.

