Brand Advisory

Who really works on your brand: the pitch team and the team after signing

When selecting an agency, we meet people, listen to ideas and begin to build trust. Before awarding the engagement, it is worth understanding who will actually run the project, with what availability and under whose responsibility.

Sala riunioni con il team di comunicazione dell'agenzia, e distanza col cliente, nella nuova copertina del magazine digitale di Bliss

At the pitch you meet the founder. Beside them, the head of strategy and the person leading the creative work. They have studied your company, they ask pertinent questions, they grasp a problem that until then had seemed so hard to explain. The conversation works and the choice seems to take shape.

But let us imagine that, after signing, the work passes to people we have not yet met. It is a possibility: after all, those who develop the commercial relationship may have a different role from those who handle day-to-day activities.

For the client, that distinction changes the meaning of the choice. Ultimately, trust was built by talking to certain people, while the engagement will be carried out by others whose skills, availability and responsibilities we have yet to learn.

Before signing, then, there is one question every CEO should put to the agency they meet: which of you will keep working on our brand, and how?

Let’s explore it together.

The team that presents and the team that delivers

By pitch team we mean the people who take part in the agency selection: a competitive process, also called a pitch, in which several partners present their approach to an assignment. The same reasoning applies when the choice is made through meetings and proposals, without a formal pitch.

At this stage the company sees only part of the organisation. It meets those presenting the proposal, appreciates their reasoning and assesses previous work. To understand how all this will translate into the service, however, it will also need to meet those who will deliver it.

We have already covered this in our guide to choosing a marketing agency, after all. For anyone choosing a partner, one practical criterion proves very useful: part of the selection should focus on the people who will in turn work on the engagement.

What will the senior person actually do?

The word “senior” can denote experience and judgement, though for the client the term only gains value when it is clear at which point in the project these qualities will come into play.

A strategy director might contribute to the initial set-up and to major reviews. A creative lead might simply approve the work before delivery. Different contributions, each with a precise function. That is why it is important to ask the right questions.

“You will have the director’s oversight” in fact leaves many questions open. Which stages will they review? Will they take part in discussions where the direction changes? Will they be available when a problem arises that the operational team cannot solve?

Even limited involvement can be adequate, if it comes at the right moments. The problem arises when the client expects ongoing support and the partner means an occasional review. Making this clear allows you to assess the service you are buying.

Time is part of the proposal

A highly skilled person involved only marginally makes a different contribution from the same person embedded in the work on an ongoing basis. That is why knowing the names is only the first step.

The business should understand what availability is planned at each stage. Imagine two proposals that both name a creative director. In the first, they are expected to step in before every significant delivery. In the second, they will attend only the initial presentation. The job title is identical; the service is not.

It is therefore worth asking which meetings, reviews and activities are included. When the engagement is based on time allocation, the estimation method and the way any variances will be handled should also be clarified. All of this helps you read the true cost of a marketing agency.

A team may include junior staff and external specialists

Entrusting part of the execution to less experienced professionals can be a sensible organisational choice. After all, skills also grow through work, provided the level of autonomy is consistent with the engagement and the review is genuine.

Here is an example to clarify the point. A junior team member prepares a proposal, discusses it with the lead and revises it before it reaches the client. This process involves both learning and control. If, instead, the client has to spot the errors and reconstruct the reasoning behind the strategy every time, part of the supervision falls on the business.

The same applies to external specialists. An agency may bring them in for a production or a particular skill. What the client needs to know is which activity they will carry out, who will coordinate them and who will be accountable for the overall result.

The quality of an organisational structure shows precisely in the handovers between people: how information flows, who checks the work and where problems are resolved.

Meeting the people who will work on the project

Before awarding the engagement, it is worth arranging a meeting with the team.

During the meeting you might discuss, for example, a difficulty the business faces or has faced in presenting a product to a new audience. At that point, notice what questions the person who will run the project asks, and whether they can identify the missing information. Can they explain how they would tackle the problem and when they would involve a colleague?

What matters here is observing the reasoning. Even an answer that openly states a doubt can help you gauge the quality of the discussion.

Names and responsibilities must make it into the agreement

Once the team has been chosen, it is advisable to set out in the proposal or in an operational annex the key people, their intended role and how they will be involved.

A particularly useful distinction concerns who manages the day-to-day relationship and who has the authority to make a decision. The account lead may take a request without being able to approve a change of strategy, additional spend or a revision of priorities. The company should know who these matters will go to and through which route.

A RACI matrix can help make responsibilities legible, especially when several departments and suppliers are involved. Even a simple agreement should make clear who executes, who checks and who is accountable for the main decisions.

If a person changes, the knowledge must remain

Teams change. That is normal. But a relationship intended to last must set out how to handle any handovers.

The difference shows in how prepared the newcomers are. Do they know the decisions already taken? Do they know why a proposal was rejected? Do they have access to up-to-date materials, and do they understand the company’s priorities?

When this information rests in the memory of a single person, the client risks having to retell its story, paying for the handover in time and attention too. An orderly offboarding process and a suitable onboarding experience help preserve context and transfer responsibilities.

Advisory: verifying continuity between proposal and service

The first few weeks are enough to check whether the agreed model also exists in practice. Are the expected people involved? Do the reviews really take place? Do important matters reach those who can decide?

If a discrepancy emerges, it is worth discussing it early, with reference to what was agreed. It may stem from a transitional phase, an underestimated workload or expectations that were left implicit. Understanding the cause allows you to agree a correction and check the outcome.

Meanwhile, the client must also make the work possible: an internal point of contact, consistent direction and approvals within the agreed timeframes prevent the team from receiving incompatible requests. The check concerns how the relationship works, not just individual deliverables.

The key to everything is continuity between what convinced the company and what it will receive after signing. The skills presented must have a recognisable role in the engagement. The client should be able to explain who looks after its brand, which decisions they take and whom to turn to when a discussion at a different level is needed.

This is something to check while the choice is still being made. The trust built during a presentation becomes a good reason to sign when we know how day-to-day work will sustain it.

Domande frequenti

What is an agency's pitch team?

It is the group that takes part in the selection and presents the proposal to the client. It may include business development staff, strategy leads, creatives and delivery professionals. Before the engagement begins, it should be clear who will continue to work on it.

Must the team that pitches be the same as the delivery team?

Roles may differ. What matters is that the client knows the delivery team and understands what contribution the people involved in the selection will continue to make.

How do you verify the seniority of those who will work on the brand?

You can ask for relevant experience, the contributions actually made to the projects presented, and a direct discussion of a problem the business faces. It should then be made clear where and when that expertise will be used in the engagement.

Is it a problem if the agency uses junior staff?

Their involvement may be appropriate to the work required. What counts is the complexity of the tasks assigned, the support provided, the review process and the ability to bring in a senior lead when needed.

What should you ask about the availability of senior people?

Which activities they will handle, which meetings they will attend, which deliverables they will review and how they will be involved in important decisions. If a time commitment is planned, it should also be clear how it is estimated and managed.

Can rules be agreed for replacing key people?

Communication arrangements, professional requirements for those taking over and handovers can all be negotiated. Commitments should be framed according to the nature of the engagement and the agreement between the parties.

How do you assess the team once work is under way?

By comparing the work with what was agreed: people’s involvement, quality of reviews, clarity of responses, adherence to deadlines and the ability to retain information. An early check helps correct deviations before they become habits.

Fonti e riferimenti
  1. World Federation of Advertisers e VoxComm, WFA and VoxComm launch new pitch principles
  2. IPA e ISBA, Finding an Agency
BLISS®© 2026. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED
Scritto il
Contact