Cybercrime

Phishing: is it a crime? Reporting, refunds and customer protection

how to get a refund from your bank after phishing

il pishing come reato, nella nuova copertina del magazine digitale di Bliss

Let’s get straight to the point. Yes, phishing is a crime, and in many cases the bank must return the stolen money. For transactions the customer has not authorised, Italian law requires the bank to refund immediately and places on it the burden of proving any fraud or gross negligence by the customer. Yet the protections shrink considerably when it is the customer, deceived, who sends the transfer to the fraudster: and this is where most money is lost today.

In this guide we explain when a refund is due, how to claim it without losing the right, and what is changing at European level in 2026.

But if you would first like an overview of what phishing is and how it works, start with the main guide.

Phishing is a crime: what victims need to know

Phishing is not a single offence. Depending on how the attack unfolds, it may constitute fraud, computer fraud, unauthorised access to a computer system and unlawful possession of access codes. Either way, three practical aspects matter to the victim.

The first is the criminal complaint (denuncia-querela). For non-aggravated cases the law requires a complaint from the victim, to be filed within three months of the day the offence was discovered. It can be filed with the Polizia Postale, including by starting the process online, or at any police or carabinieri station.

The second is that the complaint also matters for the refund. Banks almost always ask for it as an attachment to the dispute, and the panels of the Arbitro Bancario Finanziario assess it to reconstruct the facts. The new European payments regulation, discussed below, makes it an explicit requirement for refunds of frauds in which the fraudster impersonates the bank.

The third is that criminal proceedings and the refund are separate paths. Recovering money from the fraudster through the courts is rare and slow; real protection almost always comes through your relationship with your own bank.

Fake fine notification sent via PEC, with a button to access the supposed official portal.
The fake fine demanded 198 euros and warned of an increase to 268 euros for late payment. The message came from a compromised PEC mailbox. Together with the administrative language, the certified channel made the request credible just as the deadline pushed for hasty payment.

When the bank must refund: the rules of Legislative Decree 11/2010

The rules on refunds are set out in Legislative Decree no. 11 of 27 January 2010, which transposes the European directives on payment services (now PSD2). Five principles matter to phishing victims.

Immediate refund. If the customer reports an unauthorised transaction, the bank must refund it “immediately and in any event no later than the end of the following business day” (art. 11). It may suspend the refund only where there is a justified suspicion of fraud, notifying the Banca d’Italia.

Burden of proof on the bank. If the customer denies authorising a transaction, it is the bank that must prove the transaction was correctly authenticated, recorded and accounted for. The mere fact that the customer’s credentials were used is not enough to prove that the customer authorised it, nor that they acted fraudulently or with gross negligence (art. 10).

50-euro excess. Barring wilful misconduct or gross negligence, the consumer bears a loss of at most 50 euros for the fraudulent use of the payment instrument (art. 12).

Wilful misconduct or gross negligence. If the customer acted with wilful misconduct or failed to safeguard their credentials with the required diligence, thereby committing gross negligence, the loss is theirs to bear.

Thirteen months to dispute. The transaction must be reported without delay and in any case within 13 months of the debit date (art. 9). The maximum term is no licence to wait: an unjustified delay counts against the customer.

Unauthorised transaction or a transfer you made yourself: the decisive difference

The rules just described apply to unauthorised transactions: the fraudster obtains the credentials and makes payments in your place. The most common case today, however, is different, and proves far harder to deal with for those who suffer the loss.

A fake bank employee calls (often from a spoofed number) and persuades the victim to move their savings to a “safe account” or to confirm a payment to “block a fraud”. The same happens in companies with the fake supplier fraud announcing a new IBAN.

In these cases the transfer is made by the customer with their own credentials: in law it is normally an authorised transaction, even if obtained by deception, and the right to an immediate refund does not apply. The bank can still be challenged over shortcomings in its control systems or in detecting anomalous transactions, but the route is harder.

The figures show how much this distinction matters. According to the Banca d’Italia report on fraud in the second half of 2025, cited by MilanoFinanza, frauds in which customers are manipulated into authorising the payment themselves account for 72% of the value of bank transfer fraud, and 92% of losses from fraudulent transfers fall on users. On payment cards the share borne by customers is 40%. How these scams work is explained in our guide to fake bank operator scams.

Phishing email with a link and PDF attachments presented as administrative documents.
In this campaign targeting the public administration, the email came from a compromised institutional mailbox that had already exchanged legitimate messages with the recipients. The request to view administrative documents therefore looked consistent with a genuine working relationship. The aim was to steal Microsoft 365 credentials.

Gross negligence: when the right to a refund is lost

Gross negligence is the argument banks most often use to deny a refund. The law does not define it in detail: its boundaries have been drawn mainly by the panels of the Arbitro Bancario Finanziario and the Court of Cassation. Several recurring criteria emerge from the decisions collected by Cybersecurity360.

  • Sophisticated deception is not gross negligence. According to the Rome Panel (decision no. 12005 of 1 September 2022), well-crafted spoofing, with messages arriving in the same channel as the bank’s genuine ones, does not amount to gross negligence if the message shows no obvious anomalies.
  • Ignoring obvious warning signs is. The Turin Panel (decision no. 15328 of 29 November 2022) deemed “inexcusable and grossly negligent” the conduct of a customer who had replied to a message with glaring grammatical errors.
  • Sharing codes with a third party counts against the customer. Reading out the OTP code or password over the phone, or entering them on a page reached via a link, is the circumstance that most often leads to a finding of gross negligence, especially when the confirmation message clearly indicated a payment.
  • The bank must prove strong authentication. The Collegio di Coordinamento (decision no. 13398 of 18 October 2022) clarified that the intermediary must demonstrate that it applied strong customer authentication and produce the logs reconstructing the transactions. If it fails to do so, the refund is due.
  • With compliant authentication and gross negligence, the bank is not liable. The Court of Cassation (judgment no. 7214/2023) ruled out the bank’s liability in a case where the phishing had succeeded because of the customer’s gross negligence and the authentication systems complied with the regulations.

The assessment always concerns the specific case: the same behaviour may be excusable in the face of a credible attack and grossly negligent in the face of an obviously fake message.

How to claim a refund: the step-by-step procedure

The first minutes after the attack are about limiting the damage: blocking cards, changing passwords, securing devices. You will find them in the guide on what to do immediately after a phishing attack. For the refund, the sequence is as follows.

  1. Dispute the transactions immediately. Call the bank’s official number and then formalise the dispute in writing, using the bank’s form or by PEC. List each transaction with its date and amount.
  2. File a criminal complaint and attach a copy to the refund request.
  3. Keep the evidence. Messages, emails, phone numbers, screenshots of the fake pages, call logs: they serve to show that the deception was credible.
  4. Make a written complaint if the bank does not refund you. According to Altroconsumo, for unauthorised transactions the bank must reply within 10 business days.
  5. Appeal to the Arbitro Bancario Finanziario. The appeal costs 20 euros, refunded if you win, and must be filed within 12 months of the complaint. Again according to Altroconsumo, in 2024 decisions arrived in 114 days on average and over 96% of intermediaries comply with them. The ABF decides disputes of up to 200,000 euros.
  6. Consider the ordinary courts for larger sums, for a claim for damages beyond the refund, or if the bank does not comply with the ABF’s decision.

The mistakes that most often cost victims their refund are the same ones flagged by many law firms: waiting days before disputing the transaction, not filing a police report, not submitting a written complaint, and accepting the bank’s conclusions on gross negligence without checking them.

Fraudulent text message in the name of INPS asking the recipient to verify their details via a link.
The text message presented data verification as necessary to keep receiving INPS services. The link led to a counterfeit site that also asked users to upload identity documents and payslips. A seemingly routine request thus paved the way for gathering enough information to reconstruct the victim’s identity.

What is changing: case C-70/25 and the new European regulation

Two European developments strengthen the position of victims.

The Advocate General’s opinion in case C-70/25. The case concerns a customer of a Polish bank who, via a fake link, had entered her credentials on a site imitating the bank’s. The bank had refused a refund on grounds of gross negligence. On 5 March 2026 Advocate General Rantos concluded, as reported in the press release of the Court of Justice of the EU, that the bank must refund immediately even when it suspects gross negligence: the only exception is a reasonable suspicion of fraud. Only afterwards may it ask the customer to bear the loss and, if the customer refuses, it must go to court. The opinion does not bind the Court, which will rule in its judgment: many headlines presented it as a decision already taken, but it is not.

The Payment Services Regulation (PSR). On 27 November 2025 the Council and the European Parliament reached political agreement on the new regulation. As Iusletter explains, the text introduces full reimbursement for consumers who fall victim to impersonation fraud, i.e. when the fraudster poses as their bank using its name, website, app, email or phone number. The consumer must report the matter to the police and notify the bank without undue delay; the bank must refund within 15 working days, unless there is fraud or gross negligence on the customer’s part. It is the first protection designed for transfers made by a deceived customer, but it is set to apply 21 months after entry into force, most likely in 2028.

And if it is a business account?

For a business the picture can be much less favourable. Legislative Decree 11/2010 allows the bank and a non-consumer customer to exclude by contract, wholly or in part, certain key protections: the burden of proof on the bank, the excess and the cap on the customer’s liability, as well as the deadlines for disputing (art. 2, para. 4). Microenterprises, by contrast, enjoy the same protections as consumers. The new PSR protections against impersonation fraud also refer to consumers.

For those running a company there are two practical consequences: check in the account and online banking contract which waivers have been accepted, and treat prevention as the real protection, with dual verification of IBAN changes and limits on payment orders. In the event of fraud, the same procedural steps apply and should be started as soon as possible.

In short, phishing is a crime, but the refund is won or lost in your dealings with the bank. Dispute immediately, report it, keep the evidence and do not accept a refusal without a complaint and, if necessary, an appeal to the ABF.

This article is for information purposes only and is not a substitute for a lawyer’s advice on your specific case.

Fonti e riferimenti
  1. Normattiva, Decreto legislativo 27 gennaio 2010, n. 11 – Servizi di pagamento
  2. Normattiva, Codice penale – Regio decreto 19 ottobre 1930, n. 1398
  3. Banca d’Italia, Rapporto sulle operazioni di pagamento fraudolente in Italia – II semestre 2025
  4. Banca d’Italia, Cosa fare se si è stati vittima di truffe o frodi
  5. Banca d’Italia – L’economia per tutti, Truffe: come difendersi
  6. Banca d’Italia – L’economia per tutti, Operazioni di pagamento non autorizzate: come ottenere il rimborso
  7. Arbitro Bancario Finanziario, Verifiche preliminari per presentare un ricorso
  8. Arbitro Bancario Finanziario, Invio del ricorso
  9. Corte di giustizia dell’Unione europea, Conclusioni dell’Avvocato generale nella causa C-70/25, Tukowiecka
  10. Parlamento europeo, Payment services deal: More protection from online fraud and hidden fees
  11. Consiglio dell’Unione europea, Payment services: Council and Parliament agree to step up the fight against fraud and increase transparency
  12. Il phishing è sempre un reato?
  13. Il phishing non corrisponde a un unico reato previsto dal Codice penale. A seconda di come viene realizzato, può integrare, tra gli altri, truffa, frode informatica, accesso abusivo a un sistema informatico o detenzione e diffusione abusiva di codici di accesso. La qualificazione dipende quindi dal comportamento concreto del truffatore e dalle conseguenze dell’attacco
  14. La banca deve sempre rimborsare i soldi persi con il phishing?
  15. No. La tutela è più forte quando l’operazione non è stata autorizzata dal cliente: in questo caso la banca deve normalmente procedere al rimborso e deve provare gli elementi su cui fonda un’eventuale contestazione. La situazione è più complessa quando è stata la vittima stessa, ingannata dal truffatore, a disporre il bonifico o ad autorizzare il pagamento
  16. Serve la denuncia per ottenere il rimborso dalla banca?
  17. Non sempre. Per le operazioni non autorizzate, la denuncia non è oggi una condizione generale necessaria per chiedere il rimborso, anche se è utile per documentare l’accaduto e può essere richiesta nell’istruttoria. Nel futuro quadro europeo sulle frodi da impersonificazione, invece, la denuncia alla polizia è prevista tra le condizioni per ottenere la specifica tutela. In ogni caso è opportuno segnalare subito l’accaduto alla banca e alle autorità
  18. Che cosa significa “colpa grave” nel phishing?
  19. Non basta aver commesso un errore. La colpa grave viene valutata sul caso concreto considerando, tra le altre cose, quanto fosse credibile l’inganno, quali avvisi avesse ricevuto il cliente, che cosa indicassero gli SMS o le notifiche di conferma e se siano stati comunicati codici o credenziali nonostante segnali evidenti di rischio. Spetta alla banca fornire gli elementi con cui sostiene che il comportamento del cliente sia stato gravemente negligente
  20. Posso essere rimborsato se ho effettuato io il bonifico al truffatore?
  21. È possibile contestare l’accaduto, ma la tutela attuale è meno favorevole rispetto a un pagamento eseguito dal truffatore senza autorizzazione. Se il cliente dispone personalmente il bonifico perché manipolato da un falso operatore, l’operazione è normalmente considerata autorizzata. Possono comunque essere valutate eventuali carenze della banca nel rilevare anomalie o applicare i presidi di sicurezza. Il nuovo PSR europeo prevede una tutela specifica per alcune frodi da impersonificazione, ma le nuove regole non sono ancora applicabili
  22. Quanto tempo ho per contestare un’operazione di phishing?
  23. La segnalazione deve essere fatta appena ci si accorge della frode. Per le operazioni non autorizzate il D.Lgs. 11/2010 prevede comunque un termine massimo di tredici mesi dall’addebito. Se la banca respinge la richiesta, si può presentare un reclamo scritto; per i servizi di pagamento l’intermediario ha normalmente 15 giorni lavorativi per rispondere. Dopo il reclamo è possibile rivolgersi all’Arbitro Bancario Finanziario entro dodici mesi
  24. Le stesse tutele valgono per un conto aziendale?
  25. Non sempre. Le microimprese beneficiano di gran parte delle tutele riconosciute ai consumatori. Per le altre imprese, invece, il contratto con la banca può derogare ad alcune disposizioni del D.Lgs. 11/2010. Per questo, in caso di frode su un conto aziendale, è importante verificare anche le condizioni del conto e dell’home banking, oltre a contestare immediatamente l’operazione
BLISS®© 2026. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED
Scritto il
Contact