On 28 October Stellantis presented its third-quarter results and the share price rose by 15.38% (MilanoFinanza). Adjusted operating income of €256 million beat the analyst consensus of €163 million. Two days later, in Turin, Mirafiori began another week of short-time working as the city took to the streets.
Same group. Same week. Two stories that never meet.
Or perhaps they do.
A fifteen-point rise in a single session does, in fact, speak of investor relief. But trust is built over a longer timeframe, and that timeframe tells a different story. The stock had lost over 60% since the start of the year (Bloomberg), ranking among the worst-performing large European stocks of 2026: not just in the automotive sector. And on 23 October it had fallen 6.3% in a single day.
A rebound measures a moment. Reputation measures a season.
Two stories about the same group
Two stories, then, converge behind the Stellantis group logo. The first story belongs to the markets. It speaks of liquidity, efficiencies, the industrial plan. In the third quarter revenues reached €37.6 billion (Stellantis), the net loss narrowed by 90% on the comparative figure and liquidity stood at €42.7 billion. Analysts at Equita described the results as less bad than feared (Forbes). Industrial free cash flow remained negative at €4 billion, and anyone who reads financial statements knows it.
The second story, by contrast, belongs to the local communities.
In the first nine months of the year, Italian plants produced 340,745 vehicles, fewer than the 462,424 of 2020, the year of Covid. In October, six plants had production stoppages. Mirafiori closed the first half with around 36,000 cars against a target of 100,000 and placed 1,074 workers on the state wage-support scheme from 19 to 30 October. In Melfi, the union reports more than three thousand incentivised departures. In Termoli, a parliamentary question refers to 1,200 jobs lost.
No press release changes these numbers. The first story received new data on 28 October and changed direction in a single session. The second received no equivalent data and remains where it was.

Renewal that arrives once the fire is already burning
On 31 August Stellantis announced the appointment of Stephanie Hartgrove as Chief Communications Officer, effective 1 September, entrusting public policy and international relations to Clara Ingen-Housz. Further appointments reshaped European communications. These are legitimate structural choices. The group is entrusting its voice to new leadership.
The story of that renewal reached the press when negative headlines had already taken centre stage. Italian production below Covid levels, stoppages, short-time working, a share price down by more than 60%. In that context, news of a communications overhaul reads as internal information. For a Mirafiori worker, a new communications organisation chart comes from another floor.
A negative narrative takes shape in a few days. It is corrected over weeks, through actions as forceful as those that created it. An appointment, however authoritative, carries the force of an appointment.
Why the first story endures
A review published in 2001 by Roy Baumeister and colleagues, entitled Bad Is Stronger Than Good, gathers evidence from many areas of psychology. Negative events, emotions and information leave a stronger mark than positive ones of equal intensity. In 2019 a study published in PNAS measured the physiological reactions of participants in seventeen countries. The response to negative news proved more intense. Kahneman and Tversky’s prospect theory had already pointed in the same direction for economic losses, which are felt roughly twice as intensely as an equivalent gain.
For a group under scrutiny, this means the negative story starts with an advantage. Rebalancing it takes greater intensity, timing that lands within the first hours and a source perceived as credible. In our view, this is where the communications overhaul reached its limit. It came several days later, with an institutional voice and with the force of an announcement. It barely moved the needle.

The structural limits of an internal function
A communications department lives inside the group. It reports to the chief executive, shares the board’s calendar and sees the data before anyone else. It also has a boundary. The decisions that generate the narrative, such as the output of a plant, the timing of a plan or the fate of a site, are made elsewhere and reach communications once they have already been taken. A function that narrates other people’s decisions always works after the fact.
Then there is distance. Those who work every day within the same organisation share its balances, its hierarchies, its habits of interpretation. They see what the organisation allows them to see. Verifying a reputation requires an external reading, with a freedom of judgement that an internal role, by definition, does not have.
The issue concerns the architecture surrounding the role. An employee, however authoritative, occupies a single node in the organisational chart. Safeguarding a reputation requires a structure made up of periodic audits, pre-defined crisis protocols, an independent voice at the decision-making table and a single direction that holds every element together. It is the work we at Bliss call Brand Governance.
The audit before the fire
The cracks in this story were legible long before October. On 6 February the group had announced charges of over €22 billion, its first annual loss and the suspension of its dividend. In August the press was reporting that the Mirafiori relaunch was falling behind target. In early October union figures put Italian production below its 2020 level. Each element was a signal. No signal, taken on its own, produces a crisis. Together they form the ground in which a crisis takes root.
A periodic audit works on that ground. It maps the points where the organisation’s facts and the story circulating about it diverge. It identifies the stakeholders who turn a figure into news, such as unions, local communities, analysts and institutions. It measures how well the group’s messages hold up when a figure turns. It also checks how artificial intelligence systems describe the brand, because a growing share of reputation is formed there. The audit we conduct lasts eight weeks, is structured in four phases and delivers a diagnosis that comes before any strategy.
Frequency makes the difference. An audit carried out once captures a moment. An audit repeated every year and at every structural event, such as an industrial plan, a site closure or a change of leadership, builds a time series. Those who have a time series spot the gap while it is still small and act while it costs little.

The external adviser when the sea turns rough
When a crisis ignites, time is measured in hours. The first forty-eight or seventy-two set the frame within which the affair will be remembered. An external advisor enters that window with three advantages the internal structure cannot have at the same moment. Independence of judgement, because they are not answerable for the history that produced the crisis. Experience of other crises, which lets them recognise the trajectory before it unfolds. The freedom to tell the chief executive what the organisation struggles to say.
The work resembles that of a harbour pilot. The pilot boards when the ship is already in difficult waters, knows the coast, takes the helm for the stretch that matters and hands it back safely to the captain. The Brand Recovery Program follows this logic. Oversight is activated within forty-eight or seventy-two hours and continues with a ninety-, one-hundred-and-eighty- and three-hundred-and-sixty-five-day plan.
There remains the matter of facts. No communications strategy replaces an industrial decision. The advisor works on the relationship between what the organisation decides and what it says, and brings to the table a measure of the reputational consequences of each choice before it is announced. A short-time working announcement accompanied by a plan for the local area produces a different story from an isolated announcement.
The lesson for every board of directors
Stellantis provides the case. The lesson belongs to anyone who leads a large organisation. Reputation is built by decisions and measured by the story that follows them. Whoever governs the decisions also governs the story, with the same structure, the same calendar, the same accountability.
Three checks remain open in every boardroom. The first concerns the last time an external, independent reading examined the organisation’s weak points, before the press found them. The second concerns the time the structure takes, after a negative event, to bring together those who decide, those who communicate and those who know the facts. The third concerns who, in the room, is tasked with flagging that a decision ready to go carries a reputational cost that no balance sheet records.
Reputation oversight is decided before anyone asks for it. Those who decide it in advance have time on their side.
Domande frequenti
What is the difference between a reputational audit and media monitoring?
Media monitoring records what has already been published. An audit traces back to the structure that makes a story possible: the internal facts, the stakeholders, the messages, the vulnerabilities. The first delivers a chronicle. The second delivers a diagnosis.
How often should an audit be carried out?
Every year and at every structural event, such as an industrial plan, a reorganisation, an extraordinary transaction or a change of leadership. The time series of results builds lasting value, because it makes the gap visible while it is still small.
Is a high-profile Chief Communications Officer enough to manage a crisis?
A Chief Communications Officer leads the group's voice and is an indispensable role. In a crisis, what is also needed is an independent reading, a protocol already in place and direct access to the decision-making table. When these conditions are built beforehand, the role operates with a structure behind it.
When should an external advisor be brought in?
Before the crisis, for audits and protocols. During the crisis, within the first forty-eight or seventy-two hours, while the narrative frame is still open. After the crisis, to rebuild trust through actions that can be verified over time.
How do you measure the rebalancing of a reputation after a crisis?
With indicators that span several levels. Tone and volume of coverage, the behaviour of investors and suppliers, brand searches, sentiment among employees and local communities, how artificial intelligence systems describe the brand. Rebalancing is read over time and requires repeated measurement using the same method.
Fonti e riferimenti
- Stellantis, Stellantis comunica i risultati finanziari del terzo trimestre 2026
- Forbes Italia, I conti di Stellantis in ripresa: ricavi +1%, perdita ridotta del 90%
- Filosofare sui mercati, Stellantis, azioni e bond ai minimi alla vigilia dei conti
- Il Fatto Quotidiano, Stellantis, i primi 9 mesi del 2026 sono un altro disastro: solo 340.745 veicoli prodotti
- Matteo Runchi, Stellantis ha chiesto la cassa integrazione per 1.074 operai di Mirafiori
- ANSA, Stellantis Termoli, interrogazione Torto (M5S) su futuro produttivo
- Stellantis, Stellantis nomina Stephanie Hartgrove Chief Communications Officer; Clara Ingen-Housz alla guida di Public Policy & Regulatory Strategy, International Trade
- Affaritaliani, Stellantis, nuove nomine nella comunicazione europea
- Roy F. Baumeister, Ellen Bratslavsky, Catrin Finkenauer e Kathleen D. Vohs, Bad Is Stronger Than Good
- Stuart Soroka, Patrick Fournier e Lilach Nir, Cross-national evidence of a negativity bias in psychophysiological reactions to news
- Daniel Kahneman e Amos Tversky, Prospect Theory: An Analysis of Decision under Risk

